Worked Example
Question:
Jo the Geologist has given Chris the Chemist a sample of a lead ore to identify.
The ore is most likely to be an oxide, carbonate or nitrate.
Chris uses gentle heat to decompose the lead ore in a fume cupboard.
The gas given off is then tested and the results recorded as shown below:
Test |
Observation |
appearance |
colourless gas |
odour |
odourless gas |
test with lit taper |
taper continues to burn |
test with glowing taper |
taper re-ignites |
Is Joe's lead ore an oxide, a carbonate or a nitrate?
Worked Solution: (based on StoPGoPS approach to problem solving)
What have you been asked to do?
Identify the lead ore
What information have you been given in the question?
(i) Lead ore could be an oxide, carbonate or nitrate
(ii) results of the gas tests:
Test |
Observation |
appearance |
colourless gas |
odour |
odourless gas |
test with lit taper |
taper continues to burn |
test with glowing taper |
taper re-ignites |
What is the relationship between what you know and what you need to find out?
(a) The most likely thermal decomposition reactions are:
(i) decomposition of oxide to produce oxygen gas
(ii) decomposition of carbonate to produce carbon dioxide gas
(iii) decomposition of nitrate to produce nitrogen dioxide gas
(b) Test for each of these gases:
(i) oxygen gas: colourless, odourless, supports combustion
(ii) carbon dioxide gas: colourless, odourless, does not support combustion
(iii) nitrogen dioxide gas: red-brown gas with a pungent odour
Determine the identity of the gas and infer the identity of the ore
(a) Gas is oxygen since it is odourless, colourless and supports combustion
(the lit taper was not extinguished so the gas supports combustion, the glowing taper re-ignited since the presence of oxygen allows combustion to re-commence).
(b) Since the gas is oxygen, the lead ore is most likely to be an oxide since oxides decompose to produce oxygen gas.
Is your answer plausible?
Work backwards:
(i) If the ore had been a nitrate then pungent, red-brown NO2(g) would have been produced. The gas produced was colourless and odourless so the ore is not a nitrate.
(ii) If the ore had been a carbonate then odourless, colourless CO2(g) would have been produced, but CO2(g) does not support combustion and would have extinguished the lit taper, and, would never have allowed a glowing taper to re-ignite.
So the ore is not a carbonate.
(iii) Since the ore was either an oxide, carbonate or nitrate, and since we find that it could NOT be a carbonate or a nitrate, the ore must be an oxide.
State your solution to the problem.
The sample of ore is a lead oxide.
1. "acid" refers to a non-oxidizing acid such as dilute hydrochloric acid or dilute sulfuric acid.